Comic Review // Star Wars Adventures, Vol. 1: The Light and the Dark

Back to the library finds, and this time I've picked up a little more Star Wars! I enjoyed my previous trip into the younger-reader side of the galaxy enough to give this a go. After all, a good Star Wars adventure is a good Star Wars adventure, regardless of who it's aimed at.

Unfortunately, this one turned out to be a bit of a mixed bag. There's a cracking opening story, a welcome appearance from Qui-Gon Jinn, and a few interesting ideas along the way. But there are also some stories that left me scratching my head, wondering why I was bothering.

Let's take a look.

Title: Star Wars Adventures, Vol. 1: The Light and the Dark
Page Count: 144 pages
Format: Paperback
Publisher: Disney
Creators: Michael Moreci, Ilias Kyriazis, Megan Levens, Katie Cook, Cara McGee, Nick Brokenshire, Sam Maggs, Davide Tinto, Shane McCarthy, Jordan Clark, Yael Nathan, Casey Gilly, Butch Mapa, and Daniel José Older.

Commerical info:

Brand-new middle-grade stories featuring all your favourite characters from across the Star Wars galaxy, spanning the entire Skywalker Saga and beyond!

This collection brings together three oversized stories featuring Rey, Finn and Poe; Qui-Gon Jinn and the Wookiees of Kashyyyk; and Padmé and Anakin. Alongside these are several shorter adventures featuring some familiar faces from both sides of the Force, including Kylo Ren, Darth Vader, Grand Moff Tarkin, Darth Maul and more.

The collection gathers the first six issues of the Star Wars Adventures series, originally published in 2020.

The Review

Hmmm. A mixed bag is probably the best way to describe this one. We get nine adventures spanning different periods of the Star Wars timeline, and the book kicks things off with Obstacle Course, a Rey story that I really enjoyed. Poe and Finn decide to put Rey through her paces with an obstacle course on a remote planet, giving her a chance to continue developing her Jedi skills. Unfortunately, the planet isn't quite as deserted as they thought. It's home to a collection of pirates who quickly recognise the trio and decide that capturing them for the bounty on their heads sounds like a rather good idea. It's a fun little adventure, with plenty of action and a good use of the characters. A great way to kick off the collection, and it had me looking forward to what was coming next.

We then jump all the way back to before Episode One for Life Day. Here, Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon join the Wookiees of Kashyyyk for a cultural celebration. Naturally, things don't go entirely to plan, as a group of slavers turn up hoping to capture the Wookiees and sell them into the slave markets. It's a much shorter story than the opener, but it's packed with action and has a great theme behind it. I really enjoyed this one, and it reminded me how much I'd like to see more stories featuring Qui-Gon. He's a character I'd happily spend more time with.

Edit: Actually, if anyone has recommendations for good Qui-Gon Jinn comics or novels, let me know in the comments!

Next up, we move forward to the time around Episode II for a Padmé and Anakin adventure. Set on Naboo, the pair find themselves dealing with a group of pirates demanding payment. It's okay, but I have to admit I was disappointed with this one. Anakin, future Jedi powerhouse and hero of the Clone Wars, struggles to deal with three pirates on his own? Come on, Anakin. Three pirates? Really? I know these are stories aimed at younger readers, but even so, I expected a little more from the future Chosen One. Let's move on.

And while we're moving on, can someone explain why these stories weren't arranged in chronological order?

From roughly Episode II, we suddenly jump all the way forward to Episode V with Invasion of Echo Base. This time we're following Darth Vader as he leads the assault on the Rebel base on Hoth. It's not a particularly thrilling story, mainly because we already know how things turn out. However, seeing the events from Vader's perspective is a nice touch, and it makes for an interesting change of viewpoint.

After that, things start to lose a bit of steam. We get a short Kylo Ren story exploring his conflicted nature and the difficulties of leadership, but it doesn't really do enough to grab my attention. Then the Hostage follows Darth Maul as he continues building his criminal empire. Before he can get too comfortable, however, he needs to deal with some of the old guard. It's an interesting enough premise, but again, I found myself wanting a little more from it.

Then we get a story featuring Tobias Beckett, which initially caught me off guard. This was largely down to the artwork. I didn't recognise the character at first and was left wondering who I was actually reading about. Eventually, it clicked. Would recognising Beckett earlier have improved my opinion of the story? Honestly, probably not. It didn't do much for me by the end. This is followed by another weak adventure featuring Grand Moff Tarkin. I found this one confusing and uninspiring, and it's probably the point where I started looking at how many pages I had left (Feel free to skip it and save yourself some time).

We then finally finish the collection with a story set during the High Republic era. Now, I'll be honest: I know very little about this period of Star Wars history. That probably didn't help, as I struggled to connect with the characters or get particularly invested in what was happening. There does seem to be something interesting developing here, and I suspect readers familiar with the High Republic will get more out of it than I did. Unfortunately, for someone coming into this collection without that background, it didn't quite land.

As usual, the book wraps things up with a gallery of variant covers. Always a nice little extra for anyone who enjoys seeing the different artwork.

Final Thoughts

I have to be honest: I'm a little disappointed with this one. I appreciate that Star Wars Adventures is aimed at a younger audience, and I'm certainly not expecting every story to deliver some epic, galaxy-spanning drama. But the previous collections have showen me that these stories can be entertaining, accessible and genuinely enjoyable. This volume just doesn't manage that consistently. The characters often felt a little flat, and too many of the shorter adventures failed to grab my attention. The opening Rey story was great, and I particularly enjoyed the Qui-Gon and Wookiee adventure. Those two gave me exactly what I was hoping to find when I picked this up. Sadly, the rest of the collection struggles to maintain that momentum.

It's not a terrible book, and younger Star Wars fans may get more out of it than I did. But as a collection, it feels like a missed opportunity, especially when you're calling it Volume One and hoping to get readers excited about what's coming next.

Still, that's the joy of rummaging through the library shelves. Sometimes you find a little gem, and sometimes you get a collection that leaves you wondering what might have been.

Have you read Star Wars Adventures, Vol. 1: The Light and the Dark? Did I miss something with the shorter stories, or did you find them a bit of a mixed bag too? And seriously, throw some Qui-Gon recommendations my way!

Cheers for reading, and I'll see you on the next adventure!

John - Adventures with Peps

Hi, I’m John “Peps”, the creator behind Adventures with Peps. Based in Ottawa, Canada, I’m a part-time hobbyist, content creator, and all-around geek with a love for creativity in all its forms.

What started as a fun way to share my interests has grown into a community space where I explore the things I’m most passionate about: miniature painting, wargaming, comics, sci-fi and fantasy books, and video games. Whether I’m reviewing the latest 2000 AD comic, painting a Judge Dredd miniature, diving into a Warhammer audiobook, or testing my nerves in a horror game, I bring curiosity and enthusiasm to everything I do.

https://www.adventureswithpeps.com/
Next
Next

Sector 102: The Lawmaster Bike