Book Review // The Cthulhu Casebook: Sherlock Holmes and The Shadwell Shadows – James Lovegrove

Time for something a little different! Dusting off the old Kindle, I decided to dive into an intriguing reimagining of one of literature's most famous detective duos. What happens when Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson find themselves facing something that cannot be explained by logic, reason or the usual methods of criminal investigation?

That's right. We're taking everyone's favourite consulting detective and throwing him into the world of Lovecraftian cosmic horror!

Sherlock Holmes and The Shadwell Shadows is the opening instalment of James Lovegrove's Cthulhu Casebooks, a series that brings together the Victorian world of Arthur Conan Doyle with the unsettling horrors of H.P. Lovecraft. And honestly, that sounds like a match made in heaven.

The Book

Title: Sherlock Holmes and The Shadwell Shadows
Author: James Lovegrove
Series: The Cthulhu Casebooks – Book 1
Format: Kindle Edition
Length: 448 pages

Buy: Find it on Amazon

The Blurb

It is the autumn of 1880, and Dr John Watson has just returned from Afghanistan. Badly injured and desperate to forget a nightmarish expedition that has left him questioning his sanity, Watson is close to destitution when he meets the extraordinary Sherlock Holmes.

Holmes is investigating a series of deaths in London's Shadwell district. Several bodies have been discovered, with the victims apparently having starved to death over several weeks, despite being reported alive and well only days earlier.

There are also disturbing reports of creeping shadows that inspire dread in anyone who gets too close.

Holmes initially suspects a connection between the deaths and a sinister drug lord looking to expand his criminal empire. But he and Watson soon discover that something far more powerful is at work. Something that perhaps should never have been disturbed...

The Review

As a late teenager, I remember reading the Sherlock Holmes stories and thoroughly enjoying them. In fact, this book has reminded me that I really ought to revisit those original adventures at some point. I've also been meaning to explore more of Lovecraft's work, so bringing these two worlds together seemed like a rather obvious purchase. I actually picked this one up because it was on sale, completely unaware of just how much of a following this particular blend of Holmes and Cthulhu already had. Since reading it, I've discovered there are quite a few more books exploring the same idea.

Well, that's another reading rabbit hole for me to disappear down! The concept itself is wonderfully simple. Take the infamous Sherlock Holmes, a man whose world revolves around logic, observation and rational explanation, and throw him into an adventure where even his extraordinary mind will struggle to make sense of what's happening. What's not to love?

I've always enjoyed the idea of Gaslight Cthulhu. There's something particularly effective about taking a Victorian setting, where science and superstition are often rubbing shoulders, and introducing horrors that challenge everything people believe they understand. You can blend folklore, emerging scientific discoveries, old religions and cosmic terrors to create some wonderfully atmospheric settings, and Lovegrove makes good use of that opportunity.

The book begins with something familiar to Holmes fans: a retelling of the first meeting between Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson. But this isn't quite the version we've come to know through the public writings. Instead, we're presented with what feels like Watson's original account of events, including the thoughts and experiences that were supposedly left out when his stories were prepared for public consumption. It's a clever way of approaching the familiar material, allowing Lovegrove to establish his own version of the characters while still respecting the foundations laid down by Arthur Conan Doyle.

What I particularly enjoyed was that the central mystery almost takes a back seat to the development of Holmes and Watson themselves. The case provides the framework that gets the two characters from one experience to another, but the real story is about their introduction to the occult and the way these encounters begin to change them. We're watching two men discover that the world is considerably stranger and more dangerous than they ever imagined, and that is where the book really works for me.

Holmes and Watson are both portrayed very well. Lovegrove makes some subtle adjustments to their characters, allowing a more spiritual side to emerge without losing the qualities that make them recognisable. It feels like an extension of the original characters rather than an attempt to replace them. I was particularly pleased with the treatment of Watson. In the original Doyle stories, at least from my recollection, Watson can sometimes feel more like a supporting character whose primary job is to document Holmes's brilliance. Here, he feels much more rounded and has a greater role in proceedings. We get more of his background, his experiences and the skills that make him useful in his own right.

He's not simply standing beside Holmes waiting for the next explanation. He's part of the adventure, and I really appreciated that. The relationship between the two men is also an important part of the experience. Watching them navigate these unfamiliar and increasingly unsettling circumstances gives the story an additional layer beyond the mystery itself.

Ultimately, Lovegrove manages to honour the original Doyle stories while still making the characters and setting his own. That's not always an easy balance to strike, particularly when you're taking such well-established literary figures and introducing them to an entirely different genre. But I think he pulls it off rather nicely.

Final Thoughts

I thoroughly enjoyed Sherlock Holmes and The Shadwell Shadows. It's a fascinating combination of Victorian detective fiction and Lovecraftian horror, and the two genres work together far better than you might initially expect. The familiar characters provide a comfortable starting point, while the supernatural elements gradually introduce something much darker and more unsettling. I particularly enjoyed the attention given to Holmes and Watson themselves. Rather than simply using them as recognisable names to sell a cosmic horror adventure, Lovegrove takes the time to develop their relationship and explore how these experiences affect them.

It's also managed to do something rather dangerous: give me another series of books to add to my ever-growing reading pile! I'm definitely interested in picking up the following two instalments and seeing where Lovegrove takes these characters next. If you're a fan of Sherlock Holmes, Lovecraft, Victorian mysteries or just enjoy seeing familiar fictional worlds mashed together in unexpected ways, this is well worth investigating.

Have you read The Cthulhu Casebooks? What did you think? And are there any other Sherlock Holmes stories with a supernatural or Lovecraftian twist that I should be looking out for?

Drop your recommendations in the comments. I'm always happy to discover another literary adventure!

Cheers for reading, and I'll see you on the next adventure!

John - Adventures with Peps

Hi, I’m John “Peps”, the creator behind Adventures with Peps. Based in Ottawa, Canada, I’m a part-time hobbyist, content creator, and all-around geek with a love for creativity in all its forms.

What started as a fun way to share my interests has grown into a community space where I explore the things I’m most passionate about: miniature painting, wargaming, comics, sci-fi and fantasy books, and video games. Whether I’m reviewing the latest 2000 AD comic, painting a Judge Dredd miniature, diving into a Warhammer audiobook, or testing my nerves in a horror game, I bring curiosity and enthusiasm to everything I do.

https://www.adventureswithpeps.com/
Next
Next

Movie Review // The Devil's Mouth